Egypt: Another Nation at Risk - Final

Document Details:
  • Uploaded: January, 27th 2012
  • Views: 914 Times
  • Downloads: 4 Times
  • Total Pages: 23 Pages
  • File Format: .pdf
  • File size: 1,867.98 KB
  • Uploader: GihanSS (GihanSS)
  • Category: Education > Environment
 add to bookmark | report abuse
background image
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
International –Curricula Educators Association      Editor in Chief : Gihan Sami Soliman 
Registered in Egypt 2008                                       Scientific Review: Dr. Ahemd Abdel Azeem  
Registration No. : 7451                                           
www.icea-egy.org
     
NGO under the Ministry of Social Solidarity 
 
ﺔﻴﻌﻤﺟ
 
ﻲﻤﻠﻌﻣ
 
ﺞهﺎﻨﻤﻟا
 
ﺔﻴﻟوﺪﻟا
 
 
 
background image
 
CNTENTS 
 
 
 
 
 
__ 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Serial Article 
Page 
1 Egypt: 
Another 
Nation at Risk 
2 Science 
Across 
Egypt Initiative 
3 Biodiversity 
and 
Conservation of 
Fungi in Egypt 
11 
4 Sustainable 
Education for 
Marine 
Ecosystem 
Resoration 
 
13 
5 Read 
Online  19 
6 Online 
Photo 
Albums & 
Related Articles 
20 
7 Acknowledgment 
21 
background image
 
 
 
Decades ago in the United States, the Nation at Risk  
report flared the flame of American educational 
system and took the whole nation into a new phase 
of progress in a few years due to the community 
awareness and consensus on the urgent need for 
change. Egypt today is in desperate need for such a 
call. The educational crisis in Egypt is threatening of 
an unmitigated disaster and educational reform is 
becoming a compelling need; a first - priority 
project which all the powers of the nation need to 
bolster. This reform needs to originate from general 
consensus of the community itself that a cardial 
change must find its way to the system that its 
product/graduates qualify for employment, 
globalization, social life and citizenship, for a better 
future to Egypt and to the world of which Egypt is 
part. 
 
 
Education Crisis in Egypt is plainly recognized and 
felt by all concerned and stakeholders. The 
expenditure on education has been 0.2 % of the GDP 
while in progressive countries it reaches 5% of the 
GDP, no wonder North America encompasses alone 
62% of the world's 200 top universities, according to 
the 2007 Spanish report ( Dr. Mohamed Zahran, 
2008).  Raising the spending rate with 13% all of a 
sudden with no clear plan to address the current 
problems seems like a showy solution that will only 
complicate the situation in a nation struggling to 
recover after years of corruption and months of 
idleness. Speaking of the pre-college level for 
example, the crisis demonstrates itself in two major 
dimensions: the incompetence of the national 
educational system and the commercialization of the 
so-called international education. 
 
 
National System of Education (public schools) 
In a paper for a prominent thinker, Dr. Mohamed 
Zahran, Alexandria University he states: 
 
The virtual collapse and critical 
situation of national education in 
Egypt is, evidenced in the 
emphasis on quantity versus 
quality, the multitudes of 
incompetent students, 
overcrowded classes , shortages 
or lack of resources, meager 
educational  spaces and facilities, 
shortage of  qualified teachers, 
low pay, inadequate curricula , 
poor or no labs, poor languages 
even in language schools, 
inadequate and faulty 
examinations , capitalization on 
memorization at the expense of 
comprehension , lack of fair play 
, lack of transparency, nepotism , 
partiality,… among many others. 
The result is millions of jobless" 
graduates" , who have very little 
hope in the future, and who are 
not equipped or prepared to 
work professionally , inapt , 
disqualified, inefficient , 
undependable , and barely 
accountable!. Disappointingly, 
the national development 
manpower needs are not met or 
reflected in the educational 
system, which doesn't provide 
needed professional capabilities 
or technical abilities. 
Consequently, graduates must 
receive proper training, 
additional knowledge to meet 
developmental tasks and needs. 
 
National system of education includes primary, 
preparatory and secondary stages in addition to 
technical schooling system among others, which is 
considered as the exile of the system to those 
graduating from the elementary stage (primary and 
prep.) with lowest grades. Technical school students 
are generally neglected and frustrated due to being 
Egypt: 
Another Nation at Risk
 
Gihan Sami Soliman 
Educational Consultant 
background image
 
selected on basis of lower grades and thus least 
interested to get skilled and equipped for competence 
needed for decent employment in spite of the 
desperate need for such workers. 
 
Private Schools: 
 
Private schools teach the same national curricula 
either in Arabic or translated. Translated curricula as 
of a poor quality, adding to the original problem a 
new one besides attempt of he schools to give "extra 
services" in return of the money paid for receiving 
same national curricula content by merely adding 
more language related materials rather than adding 
more hands-on activities, extra curricular activities or 
even better teaching services. Teacher training 
programs in Egypt are offered either to public school 
teachers under very restricted conditions as grants or 
is too expensive therefore private schools disregard 
the qualification issue. 
 
 
International Schools(American Diploma, 
IGCSE, Canadian,IB …etc.) 
 
No one knows the real number of those schools in 
Egypt. Formal statistics only reveal the number of 
public schools and private ones as including the 
international schools among other types. 
 
The Egyptian community generally regard  the 
international education in terms of profit, thus, no 
one seems to have had thought of including the so 
called international education in a plan for overall 
social reform. The public perception of the American 
schools for example is of a "foreign investment" as if 
those schools were not “Egyptian”. The fact is that 
those schools are mostly  "Egyptian", owned and run 
by Egyptians(Law prohibits hiring more than 10% of 
foreigners in a work venue), provide education mostly 
for Egyptians, but merely using international curricula 
and “supposedly” modern teaching methodology with 
some “International” recognition. Schools used to 
collect fees in dollars till recently when the Ministry of 
Education banned such practice. 
 
There was a hope that such "international" schooling 
system and private universities would help achieving 
some educational reform in Egypt by providing all the 
facilities, curricula and level of instruction required for 
quality education. However, most of those schools 
and universities are the product of a defective system. 
Private university would mostly use the same 
instructors, curricula and instruction methodology of 
the public universities except that parents pay an 
average of 50000 per year between tuition, daily 
expenses, books and private lessons. Same applies to 
the private schools  while the 2007 UNDP 
Development Report states that the annual per capita 
income in Egypt was $1207 (LE 6500).. as for the 
international schools, the situation is even worse. 
"The education business" now is the most lucrative 
business in Egypt. Many schools are just selling grades 
or turning into SAT centers due to perpetual problem;  
those schools are under the same defective national 
system of education, civil officers of the Ministry of 
Education are not aware of what quality education is 
or should be, with more than 140 schools applying 
one or more of the international systems, specifically 
the American. The Ministry of Education for example 
requires an “American” school to be a "at least" a 
candidate for accreditation to get a license to operate!! 
Which is pathetically putting the carte before the 
horse? A school needs to be licensed to operate and 
demonstrates competence and stability to be a 
candidate for accreditation.. Doesn't this give a hint 
on how accreditation process is going on !!  
 
Citizenship and Global Citizenship: 
 
There is a well know educational crisis in Egypt in 
regards of citizenship and global citizenship issues due 
to years and years of corruption and suppression of 
free expression of opinion. The 25
th
 of Jan. revolution 
is still conducted by the mere power of anger and no 
real systematic reform seems to be in the horizon. 
Speaking of the educational system, the World 
History book for example was banned from the 
American-curricula -teaching schools and were 
replaces by the regular social studies books taught in 
Arabic-in spite of the fact that those schools are 
classified as "international" and need to be English 
language focused- just because some of the content of 
those books did not match the Arabs' point of view in 
some points and instead of addressing such issues by 
discussion replacement of book , the world history 
title was just discarded ! Also environmental 
protection is another citizenship issue that needs to be 
background image
 
addressed when discussing politics in Egypt and the 
whole world. Environmental conservation does not 
need only scientists but politicians as well (the world 
decade of 2010 for conservation of biodiversity has 
been extended to 2012 for failing to achieve its 
objectives on time). Scientists know to point to the 
problem (fungi, their importance and uses, their 
unexplored diversity, fungal conservation training and 
the need to protect them. Some threats can already 
clearly be identified: climate change, human 
population growth, the vulnerability of Egypt’s one 
great river to pollution, and the fragility of desert 
ecosystems, the low levels of plant coverage 
encourage the misleading idea that deserts house no 
biodiversity: Ahmed Abdel Azeem, 2011). but 
politicians are the ones who decide what to do about 
such problem. Environmental conservation is part of 
global citizenship then but education in Egypt does 
not address such problem as biodiversity is known to 
be the degree of variation of life forms within a given 
ecosystem and thus it's a rather "local" issue besides 
being global. For students in the US and the so called 
"American Schools" in Egypt for instance, science 
and environmental science are studies through the 
American textbooks focused on the American cultural 
heritage and environment.. However, in Egypt and 
especially with the schools that use the international 
textbooks (International Schools) there is hardly any 
real relationship between science and the 
environment, and social studies with citizenship issues 
and policy making. 
 
Several attempts at reform have been made in regard 
to enhancing education in Egypt and raising 
awareness of politics and global citizenship issues, but 
they're usually confined to issuing some booklets, 
CDs and posters which are not systematically 
presented to students and end up sitting on school 
libraries shelves and closets , 
 
A blatant example of corruption in regards of this 
issue is this project ;(e.g. www.biomapegypt.org ). The 
information on the website would be that of any 
regular tourism website but try to push the button of 
"database" and it's not working! The whole project is 
void of its database.   
 
 
As an educational consultant I have taken several 
initiatives to raise the awareness of citizenship and 
global citizenship issues in Egypt in relation to 
education (K-12) with some prominent figures in 
science and politics, to address the gap of knowledge 
and interest in citizenship issues. Through The 
Citizenship and Global Citizenship in the Egyptian 
Schools Project . I have succeeded in promoting the 
self financing Science Across Egypt© project which 
aims at integrating conservation of biodiversity into 
curricula and extra-curricular activities in "Egyptian 
schools." But remains the attempt of integrating 
leadership, political awareness, citizenship and 
decision making abilities as an area of the project that 
needs support and funding.  
 
Religion textbooks boost more of sectarian 
segregation and isolation and do not support 
tolerance. 
 
 
" Egypt: Another Nation at Crisis "Project 
Goals
:  
 
1) Establishing an online library for all educational 
materials and research addressing the issue of 
citizenship and global citizenship in relation to 
education as well as providing free access on all 
available information of biological life in Egypt in 
relation to conservation of nature. 
2) Conducting polls, research and studies on the 
awareness of stakeholders on environmental issues 
and present endorsed results online.  
3) Train science (Science Across Egypt© project
1
)and 
social studies teachers on addressing the curricula 
design and activities of sciences to integrate such 
issues 
 4) Promote interest among school children with the 
citizenship (decision making, leadership, political 
awareness) and global citizenship issues (tolerance, 
diversity, global warming, pollution, international 
conventions regarding conservation and peace) 
5) Integration of citizenship issues into the curricula 
and extra curricular activities of the "American 
Schools" in Egypt using the flexibility of curriculum 
design option associated with the American system 
                                                           
1
  
background image
 
and propose the books to be approved by the 
Ministry of Education. 
6) Lobbying for the desired change on both the 
national and international level. 
 
 
Teacher Training: 
 
Speaking of Private education, Teachers are generally 
hired for their fluency in English (regardless of the 
accent) not for their skills or qualifications simply 
because recognized teacher certification is too 
expensive for the average teacher besides it's 
irrelevant to the needs of an Egyptian learning 
environment.  Teachers are categorized in term of 
salary into two major categories; foreigners and AUC 
graduates, and Egyptians(including "local foreigners 
as well"). “AUCians” are not necessarily educators. 
"Foreigners" are mostly Europeans that are not-most 
of the time-native English speakers or educators but 
only hired for their Caucasian physical appearance 
which appeal to the parents who had paid a fortune to 
enroll their kids into an "international school". 
Teacher training programs are carried on briefly as 
staff development for schools as a requirement of 
accreditation and consequently it is not effective 
enough to help individual needs and cannot help fresh 
graduates to find a place into this” business”.  
 
Speaking of the national system of education, teacher 
training is useless for the lack of facilities and the 
poor leadership/governance for schools. 
 
ICEA is organizing a teacher training program in 
partnership with the University Education 
Development Center at Ain Shams University to 
qualify teachers to work in the International Schools 
in Egypt for the first time, with a special focus on 
science teachers. 
 
Standardized Testing: 
 
 
When the Ministry of Higher Education finally 
became aware of the incompetence of this system’s 
product/graduates, they decided to interfere and 
pathetically raised the ratio of SAT score requirement 
for college admission to 60% of the total score, while 
the SAT test is not an achievement test and is not 
designed to assess the student’s learning. That only 
worsened the situation and boosted the phenomena 
of selling the other 40% required for graduation in the 
very famous issue of grade inflation and selling 
diplomas in addition to the rising need for condensed 
SAT training courses to reach the now-raised-to 
minimum of 1440 scores required for college 
admission. The average annual fees for a non-top 
school is LE 20,000 in addition to the fees of 
stamping those diploma from the accrediting 
organization then getting it stamped from the 
Egyptian Cultural Attaché in Washington and now re-
stamped again at the Egyptian Examination 
Authority. This commercializing of education is 
affecting the whole community , The rise of the 
education bill that is not a “money back guarantee” is 
boosting prices of goods, services and real estate and 
thus maximizing the cost, burdens and despair  in 
every household!  
 
Those kind of diplomas were at a point a hideaway 
from the general diploma "Thanaweya Amma" that 
costs almost the same with all the private tutoring in 
public schools. 
 
Quality of Education: 
 
Quality of education in Egypt is being controlled by 
two kinds of entities that are presumably independent. 
American accrediting organizations and a national one 
NAQAAE. The National authority for accrediting the 
quality of education was established after the 
American model assuming that national and private 
schools have the choice to develop their own 
curricula and therefore their separate vision and 
mission which is evidently not true. Thus thousands 
of pounds are spent every year on accrediting schools 
that cannot control the quality of education they 
provide, their curricula and even their budget. A 
public school pays around LE 30000 for each stage to 
get accredited and who pays that bill?  
 
As for the American entities schools are required to 
be candidate for accreditation before they get a license 
to operate! Which indicate the fallacy of the process 
itself turning into a facility accreditation rather than 
quality assurance process. 
 
Education and Community: 
background image
 
 
International-Curricula educators Association was 
established in 2008 in a vision of mobilizing the 
educational community for reform. International-
Curricula Educators is a not-profit Egyptian 
organization that 
was proclaimed 
legal ender the 
Ministry of Social 
Solidarity on 
October, 2008 
with the vision of 
establishing an 
educational community for the first time in Egypt that 
focuses on the sector of international education in 
Egypt, fostering educators, students and 
administrators working on the international level as 
they have the best access to quality education but the 
poorest contribution and dedication to the home and 
global issues such as environmental issues ,, , 
citizenship and global citizenship and that’s because 
their curricula are not Egyptian and not even 
“customized” international.  Some international. 
Accrediting associations require community 
participation but that’s usually in terms of involving 
stakeholders in decision making and school activities 
not “community welfare” issues and “community 
service”,  Corruption, competition over the 3.5 % 
allocated for the international-schools students in the 
Egyptian universities (=low college fees), cut throat 
competition over qualifying grades for college, the 
60% SAT issue and raising the minimum SAT score 
to 1440 for the American sections, accreditation 
turning into licensure and the lack of awareness are 
among the main reasons how education went it’s 
current crisis in Egypt. 
 
 
The scarcity of research on this topic was a great 
frustration when we started our work to achieve 
REAL educational reform in Egypt and the work on 
the environment was one of the biggest challenges.. 
we set our objective on raising the public awareness in 
general and the students’ in particular that we get the 
whole society to work on protecting the 
environment.. 
 
On the 5th of June 2010, among other NGOs,  we 
went out on the protest against pollution On Manzala 
Lake in Port Said and on the Water Day, 2011 we 
went out to the river Nile with Port Said American 
School, Zamalek with our scientific consultant Dr. 
Ahmed Abdel Azeem to test the water and analyze 
the results then initiate the call to have the Nile as a 
protectorate. There are several protectorates in Egypt 
such as Wadi Degla and St Kathrine but few students 
have visited them or even made aware of their 
existence and thus we designed camps and field trips 
to such areas. We also aimed at supporting 
participatory assessment exercises among stakeholders 
to identify and harness the wealth of knowledge, 
skills, resources and institutions of importance for 
conservation that are available in society in an 
overview to assess key threats to protected areas and 
develop and implement strategies to prevent and/or 
mitigate such threats. 
 
One of the key objectives we had when we started 
working on the environment issue as well was the 
integration of climate change adaptation measures in 
protected area in Egypt and strategies to provide 
more protection and more public interest in them in 
the curricula as those curricula are designed for 
American/Canadian/ 
British/ …etc citizens 
but they have a flexibility 
to be customized for 
Egyptian citizens that 
has evidently not been 
explored before. 
 
 We have succeeded to a 
satisfactory extent on 
achieving our goals and 
our campaigns started 
getting publicized in the press but yet we think we 
need to develop a more serious interest in the 
protection of environment in Egypt and encourage 
research, in addition to fostering researchers on the 
background image
 
environmental issues, thus the work continues on 
establishing a database for the current research and 
getting sponsors for our awareness campaigns as they 
still depend on volunteerism and self-funding. 
 
 
•  The three main objectives we had:  
 
  Education for 
Sustainable 
Development. 
  Education for 
Citizenship. 
  Education for 
Global Citizenship. 
 
•  Our initiatives: 
 
Egypt: Another Nation at Risk! 
Science Across Egypt 
Egypt's Got Talents 
International Foundation for Environmental 
Protection and Sustainability. 
[www.ifeps.org] 
•  Our campaigns: 
 
•  We won't give up 
•  Our Environment is Our Life  
 
•  Biodiversity and Fungal conservation  
•  Saving the Egyptian Cultural Heritage 
•  Green Buildings  
•  Safe Collection and disposal of batteries. 
 
References ; 
 
 
 
  
 
 
 .  
 
 
http://ocs.balwois.com/index.php?conference=BALWOIS&sc
hedConf=BW2012&page=paper&op=view&path%5B%5D=9
43
 
 
www.portsaidamerican.blogspot.com
   
 
         
 
 
 
 
  
 
 
 
 
www.mohsenzahran.com/paper/A_Betrayal_of_Conscience.
doc
 
 
background image
 
 
 
Abstract— Science Across Egypt©2 
is an program started in 2009 as an initiative aiming at: 
  
1) Curriculum Relevance:  
A- Lobbying for reforming science curricula at the 
National schooling system (National Curriculum) to 
related science to life and environment as the current 
methodology used in writing text books is inefficient. 
B- Curriculum design and mapping for the 
International schools to eliminate the use of the 
"exported" textbooks without integration of local 
issues and concerns (life and environment) 
2) Providing recognized training program for science 
teachers to develop the pedagogy and teaching 
methods of science specially to include field trips and 
more hands-on activities. 
3) Raising awareness on the environmental issues in 
Egypt by carrying out campaigns conducted by school 
children. 
4) Attracting local and international attention to the 
urgent need of support of educational reform 
education in Egypt on a grass-root level. 
  
  
Keywords; science across Egypt; educational reform; 
Egypt; Education and the community, International-
Curricula Educators Association. 
Since 1936, when Egypt became a party to the 
Convention Relative to the Preservation of Fauna and 
Flora in their Natural State, they have been among the 
pioneering countries taking an active interest in the 
conservation of biodiversity and the preservation of 
natural resources. In 1992, Egypt signed the 
Biodiversity Convention of Rio de Janeiro and 
ratification of this Convention was completed in 
1994. This Convention required the parties to 
formulate national strategies setting a framework for 
the conservation of biological diversity (biodiversity). 
                                                           
2
 
Although much “technical” attention has been paid to 
biodiversity in Egypt, with many conferences, 
recommendations and ratification of laws, the 
problem of an evidently defective system of education 
in Egypt means that the right information on 
conservation doesn’t seem to reach the right people: 
students. 
Teaching methods in Egypt need to be addressed, 
particularly in relation to biodiversity. Biodiversity is 
the degree of variation of life forms within a given 
ecosystem and is a measure of the health of 
ecosystems. Biologists define biodiversity as the 
“totality of genes, species, and ecosystems of a 
region.” For students in the US, biodiversity is studied 
as a science; students can explore textbooks and 
review material according to their curriculum, which 
is usually based on each state’s learning standards 
(Figure 1). However, in Egypt there is hardly any real 
relationship between science and the environment, 
making learning about these issues difficult. 
Several attempts at reform have been made to 
enhance science education in Egypt and raise 
awareness of biodiversity issues. However, they’re 
usually confined to issuing books, booklets, CDs and 
posters which are not systematically presented to 
students and end up sitting on school library shelves 
and hidden away in cupboards (e.g. 
www.biomapegypt.org ). 
As an 
educational 
consultant 
working with 
Ahmed Abdel 
Azeem, Ph.D, I 
have started 
working with 
schools on a 
self-financing 
environmental and applied science project called 
Science Across Egypt©. The project’s aim is to 
integrate conservation of biological diversity into 
Science Across Egypt©Initiative 
A make-change step in the education in Egypt 
 
Gihan Sami Soliman & Dr. Ahmed Abdel Azeem 
background image
 
10 
curricula and extra-curricular activities in “Egyptian 
schools”.:
 
The Science Across Egypt project carries 
out many initiatives that aim to teach children more 
about the environment. As an example, on 
International Water Day on March 22, 2011, students 
of Port Said American School 
were accompanied to the Nile River bank to celebrate 
the event and take water samples to measure the level 
of pollution onsite. They also campaigned for 
declaring the river Nile as a natural protectorate 
(Figure 2). The Media reported the event as being a 
unique opportunity for children to learn more about 
the environment. 
 
Reforming science education in Egypt will need more 
determined 
efforts on both 
national and 
international 
levels (Figure 3). 
Taking a step in 
this direction, for 
the first time in 
Egypt, a group of 
scientists and 
attentive 
community leaders have established an international 
Egyptian NGO (International Foundation for 
Environment Protections and Sustainability) to 
address the issues of biodiversity in Egypt 
(www.ifeps.org ). Will such efforts work? Let’s keep 
our fingers crossed. 
Science Across Egypt and Saving the Cultural 
Heritage: 
 
Egypt has the third of all world monuments and 
unless education on the importance of such heritage, 
its protection, restoration and preservation is 
provided to the Egyptian public and specially 
students, the world might lose some access to such 
great treasures.. ICEA is leading  campaign to raise 
awareness on the importance of preserving our 
cultural and natural heritage that starts from schools 
outward. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Qawmeya American School Agoza, 2012
Port Said Experimental School, Port Said 
Displaying 10 of 23 pages, to read the full document please DOWNLOAD.